The short answer
A roof usually fails because something beneath or around the covering gives way first: corroded or fatigued fixings, perished underlay, rotten battens, poor ventilation, a covering laid below its minimum pitch, or workmanship that never met the manufacturer's laps and fixings. Age and weather speed these causes up, but they are rarely the root.
Fixings that corrode and tire
Every slate, tile and stone slate hangs on a fixing, and fixings are the usual point of first failure. Steel nails rust where water sits around them. Aluminium and copper nails resist that far better, which is why they are the usual choice for slate. Hooks and clips can loosen as the timber behind them moves with damp and heat.
On a Cotswold stone roof the fixing is an oak peg. Cotswold District Council's technical guidance describes cleft oak pegs, sometimes two together, passed through a hole near each slate's upper edge. When the peg softens or snaps, the slate slips, and the course above loses part of its support.
Fatigue is slower. Wind lifts and drops a covering thousands of times, each movement working a nail a little looser in its batten. We look for slipped tiles, gaps in courses and uneven tail lines from the ground, then check the underside from the loft. We check early on whether the same fixing failure repeats along a course, because that points to a pattern and not an accident.
Underlay that perishes and battens that rot
Underlay is the second layer of defence. It catches whatever the covering lets through and guides it to the gutter. Older felt hardens and tears where it was never laid with enough lap, and it can fail from the underside if the loft is damp. Once it splits, every wind-driven shower reaches the timber beneath.
Battens, the timber laths that hold up the covering, take that water next. Softwood that stays wet for long enough decays, and a rotten batten can no longer grip a nail. From the garden the roof may look fine while slates are quietly shifting. Our page on battens and underlay in a re-roof covers the replacement side.
Rafters and wall plates are the last to go, but when water reaches them the repair stops being a roofing job and becomes a structural one. Replacing timber is costly in labour, which is why catching the problem at the batten stage saves so much.
Daylight in a dark loft, brown tide marks on rafters and a musty smell are all clues that water has been coming in for a while.
Ventilation, condensation and the loft
Moisture comes from inside as well. Cooking, washing and breathing put damp air into the house, and it rises into the loft. If the roof void cannot breathe, that moisture condenses on cold timber and underlay, and the damp that results looks exactly like a leak.
BS 5250, as summarised by Marley, sets out eaves and ridge ventilation for a cold roof, and the amount depends on which underlay is used and how steep the roof is. Insulation stuffed hard into the eaves, blocked soffit vents or a poorly sealed ceiling hatch can all undo that. Adding insulation while closing off air paths is a common way to create a new problem.
Foam sprayed under the roof covering deserves particular care. RICS warns that incorrect installation can lead to dampness, and its consumer guide advises asking your lender and insurer whether they accept it before any work goes ahead. Timber hidden behind foam cannot be inspected, so a fault can run for years unseen.
Wrong pitch, wrong covering
Every covering has a minimum pitch below which water can be driven back up the laps. Marley lists 35 degrees for its concrete plain tiles and 15 degrees for its Mendip and Wessex tiles. Natural slate to BS 5534 is generally laid at 20 degrees or more with the headlap the exposure demands, according to Cupa Pizarras. Those figures are for particular products and exposures, so the data sheet decides.
Problems appear when a roof is re-covered with something that suits a different slope. A tile fixed on too shallow a slope can leak in a heavy shower even when every fixing is sound. A heavier covering than the old one can overload the timbers beneath it. Our guide to signs your Stroud roof needs replacing lists what those problems look like once they start.
Flat roofs have their own version of the same mistake. A deck laid with too little fall holds water, and standing water ages a membrane quickly.
Workmanship and neglect
Poor workmanship lies behind many early failures: short laps, nails driven too far or not far enough, underlay left unsupported, flashings dressed without a proper step or upstand, ridge tiles on mortar alone when BS 5534:2014 expects mechanical fixing as well. None of it shows on the day the scaffold comes down.
Neglect completes the picture. Gutters left blocked send water back under the first course. Moss holds damp against slates and splits them in a frost. A single slipped tile left for years lets in enough to rot a batten. Age matters mainly because it multiplies those chances, which is why age against condition is a better test than the date on the roof.
Fixing a cause is often cheaper than replacing the result. A survey, with pictures taken on your roof, shows which of these causes applies, and the quote that follows covers a repair or a new covering, so the choice is yours. For the wider picture, start with roof replacement in Stroud.
Where several of these causes overlap, the order of repair matters. Fixing ventilation before laying a new underlay, or correcting a pitch problem by choosing a covering that suits the slope, stops the same fault coming back under fresh tiles.