Quick answer

A cracked asbestos garage roof sheet: what now?

One cracked sheet is not an emergency on its own, but it is a change. Leave it alone, keep people away from it, and get the roof looked at before anything is moved.

The short answer

Do not touch, sweep up or tape the sheet. A crack, or a few loose pieces, does not mean you must evacuate, but it does mean the roof is no longer in the same state as whole sheeting. HSE guidance treats substantially damaged asbestos cement as notifiable non-licensed work. Keep people away, photograph it from a safe distance and ask a contractor to survey it.

Why a crack can change the HSE category

The Health and Safety Executive files careful, whole-sheet removal of cement roofing under non-licensed work, and treats ordinary weathering as no reason to change that. Damage is another matter. Its page on notifiable non-licensed work names cement roof sheeting broken up badly, by fire or flood for instance, as work the contractor must report.

A hairline crack is not necessarily substantial damage. A sheet in several pieces, a missing corner or a section dropped into the garage probably is. The call is made on site, with the roof in front of you, which is why a photograph and a survey count for more than a guess from the lawn. Either way, the roof is now one to treat with more care than it was last week.

Steps to take until a surveyor has looked

The principle is to leave the damage undisturbed and limit who goes near it. Steps that help:

  • Keep children, pets and visitors away from the garage and from the ground directly below the damaged sheet.
  • Photograph the damage from a distance, and from inside if you can see it, without climbing or leaning on the roof.
  • Shut the garage door if wind is blowing debris about, and stop using the space as a workshop or play area.
  • Move vehicles or valuables out only if you can do it without brushing against loose fragments.

Fibres become a problem when material is disturbed and dust is released, so calm handling is the whole game at this stage. Wet weather and wind both make a damaged roof harder to leave alone, which is why an early call to a contractor is sensible.

What not to do

Resist the urge to tidy. Do not sweep, vacuum or hose fragments from the floor, because that lifts dust into the air. Do not snap the sheet further to get it out of the way, put pieces in an ordinary bin bag, or take them to the household tip in the boot of the car. Do not tape or paint over a crack in the hope of sealing it, and do not drill or screw into the sheet to hold a patch.

Cement waste of this kind has its own disposal route. Our guide to how an asbestos garage roof is removed describes the careful method for sheeting that is still whole, including wrapping, controls and the waste leaving site correctly. Damaged sheet follows the same principles with more safeguards on top.

Storms, falling branches and other ways a sheet breaks

Sheets rarely crack for no reason. A branch coming down in a gale, a ladder leant against the edge, a ball or a person stepping onto brittle cement, and years of freeze and thaw working at an old bolt hole are the usual causes. Which one it was matters for two practical reasons.

First, a sheet that failed because of a single event may leave the rest of the roof sound, which can make a short-term cover-over more reasonable while you arrange a survey. Second, a sheet that cracked because the whole roof is tired points to more cracks to come, and patching one panel only moves the problem along. If a storm did it, your insurer may need to hear about it; our answer on whether home insurance covers a garage roof explains the usual dividing line between sudden damage and wear.

What a contractor must do for broken sheet

When the work counts as notifiable, the contractor has three things to do that an ordinary roofing job does not involve. They tell the enforcing authority before starting, using an online form, since the HSE gives no minimum notice period. They make sure their workers are medically examined. And they keep a register of the job as a health record, which must be retained for 40 years.

You do not fill in that form, but you do pay for the extra controls, so a cracked roof prices above the same roof with every sheet whole. Ask any contractor how the work will be notified, what controls they will use on site and where the waste goes. If they cannot answer plainly, keep looking.

Keeping the garage dry and weighing up the new roof

If rain is getting in, the sensible first move is to stop the water without disturbing the sheet, for example by covering the contents inside the garage rather than going up to the roof. Water coming through is dealt with first, and the roof made safe before anything else. A cover over a damaged sheet that needs someone to climb on it is a different matter, so do not attempt it yourself.

A sound new roof ends the problem for good, whereas patching old cement sheet rarely does. After the survey, with photographs of your own garage, the written quote covers access, controlled take-down, waste disposal, the new roof and clearing the site, so you know the whole job is accounted for. What governs the timing is covered in how long a garage roof replacement takes, and the cold months in garage roof work in winter. For the wider service, see garage roof replacement in Stroud. Afterwards we clear the site completely, and the new roof carries a 10-year workmanship guarantee in writing.

Get your roof priced

Tell us what's happening and we'll call you back with a time to look at it.

  • Guide prices before we visit
  • A written quote
  • 10-year workmanship guarantee

Rather talk? 01453 933613

Call Get a quote